Shi V. Liu's Open Letters to Nobel Prize Selection
Committee: 2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
Shi V. Liu¡¯s Criticisms on iPS Cell Research
(Updated 2010-07-23)
|
Title |
Reference |
|
iPS
cells: stem cells induced from terminally differentiated cells or just
pre-existing stem cells being detected? |
Logical Biol.7: 63-65, 2007 |
|
Stop a fundamental cheating in reporting cloning
research |
Top Watch 2: 25-27, 2007 |
|
Egg- or- embryo-free creation of patient-specific
stem cells from skin cells: Give me a break |
Top Watch 2: 37-38, 2007 |
|
Are iPS cells really indistinguishable
from ES cells? |
Logical Biol.7: 66-68, 2007 |
|
Further comments on
the nature of iPS cells |
Logical Biol.7: 69-72, 2007 |
|
Rebuttal against an authoritative but ungrounded
peer review |
Logical Biol.7: 73-75, 2007 |
|
Higher scientific and ethical standard for
reporting therapeutic cloning |
Top Watch 2: 90-93, 2007 |
|
Can the iPS airplane really fly high in the
therapeutic sky? |
Logical Biol.7: 84-86, 2007 |
|
Nuclear transplantation-derived embryonic stem
cells are distinct from those emerging from fertilization |
Logical Biol.7: 91-93, 2007 |
|
Alternative views on the formation of iPS cells |
Logical Biol.7: 94-95, 2007 |
|
Induction of
pluripotency: Where is the evidence? An open letter to cell and Yamanaka |
Top Watch 2: 94-96, 2007 |
|
Western ¡®radars¡¯ should
detect Chinese ¡®airplanes¡¯ |
Top Watch 2: 97-98, 2007 |
|
A real therapeutic stem
cell ¡®airplanes¡¯ in |
Top Watch 2: 99-100, 2007 |
|
On Nature¡¯s
safety net for crashing iPS airplanes |
Top Watch 2:103-104, 2007 |
|
Christmas sale for iPS
¡°airplanes¡± |
Top Watch 2: 105-108, 2007 |
|
Invalidating the induction claim and adopting
an activation mechanism for stem cells useful for regenerative medicine |
Logical Biol.7: 96-99, 2007 |
|
Are iPS cells really induced from
differentiated cells? |
Logical Biol.8: 1-7, 2008 |
|
Can Yamanaka Explain His
Contradictory Statements? |
Logical Biol.8: 13-15, 2008 |
|
IPS Cells Are Man-Made Cancer Cells |
Logical Biol.8: 16-18, 2008 |
|
Open Letter to Nobel Prize Selection Committee
against Awarding Yamanaka and other iPS Cell Researchers |
Top Watch 3:1-3, 2008 |
|
Understanding the ¡°Reprogramming¡± Process in
¡°Inducing¡± iPS Cells |
Logical Biol.8: 19-22, 2008 |
|
A simple experiment to verify the ¡®direct
reprogramming¡¯ claim on iPS cell ¡®induction¡¯ |
Logical Biol.8: 23-24, 2008 |
|
On the Oct-4 reporting chaos |
Logical Biol.8: 25-26, 2008 |
|
Sequential reprogramming of differentiated cells
into iPS cells or sequential differentiation of transformed pre-existing stem
cells? |
Logical Biol.8: 27-29, 2008 |
|
Repeated applications do not validate ¡®induction¡¯ of
stem cells by iPS technique |
Logical Biol.8: 30-31, 2008 |
|
Towards a Balanced View on iPS Cells |
Logical Biol.8: 32-38, 2008 |
|
One Factor Dropped from the 'Inducing' Soup, One Piece
of Evidence Added against the 'Induction' Claim |
Logical Biol.8: 39-41, 2008 |
|
5 Reasons to Get off the iPS ¡°Airplane¡± |
Logical Biol.8: 42-46, 2008 |
|
Re-Learn the Polywater Lesson for iPS Cells |
Top Watch 3:7-8, 2008 |
|
iPS Cells and Pseudoscience: a Huge Detour in Stem
Cell Research |
Top Watch 3:9-11, 2008 |
|
iPS Cells versus ES Cells |
Logical Biol.8: 47-48, 2008 |
|
Paying Attention to the Underlying Meaning of
Understatements for iPS Cells |
Top Watch 3: 12-13, 2008 |
|
Credit for Critics and a Whole Story for iPS Cells |
Sci. Ethics 3: 6-7, 2008 |
|
On the Rates of Establishing ntESC and the
Hope for Improvements |
Logical Biol.8: 49-51, 2008 |
|
Evidence
for selection of pre-existing stem cells rather than induction of iPS cells |
Logical Biol.8: 52-54, 2008 |
|
iPS Confusion and Clarification |
Logical Biol.8: 55-56, 2008 |
|
The Final Blow-up of the Induction
and Reprogramming Claim for iPS Cells |
Logical Biol.8: 57-61, 2008 |
|
The |
Logical Biol.8:62-67, 2008 |
|
Further Evidence that iPS Cells Are
Man-Made Cancer Cells |
Logical Biol.8: 66-68, 2008 |
|
iPS Cells: A More Critical Review |
Stem Cells and Dev. 17:391-397, 2008 |
|
Getting Safer iPS Cells or Reaching an iPS Dead-End? |
Logical
Biology 8 (4):82-86, 2008 |
|
Toward a Realistic Re-Assessment of iPSCs |
Logical Biology 9
(1):6-7, 2009 |
|
Embryonic and adult education on stem cells |
Logical Biology 9
(1):8-9, 2009 |
|
Are Generation 2 iPSCs Really
Safe? |
Logical Biology 9
(1):12-13, 2009 |
|
Cancer Risk May Still Present in Episomally Transformed iPSCs |
Logical Biology 9
(1):14-15, 2009 |
|
Some Concerns about Protein-Induced
Pluripotent Stem Cells (piPSCs) |
Logical Biology 9
(1):16-18, 2009 |
|
Credit for Critics and a Whole Story for
iPS Cells |
Scientific Ethics 3(1): 6-7, 2008 |
|
Re-Learn the Polywater Lesson for iPS Cells |
Top Watch 3(1):7-8, 2008 |
|
iPS Cells and Pseudoscience: a Huge Detour
in Stem Cell Research |
Top Watch 3(1):9-11, 2008 |
|
Paying Attention to the Underlying Meaning
of Understatements for iPS Cells |
Top Watch 3(1):12-13, 2008 |
|
An April Fool¡¯s Spinning on iPS Cells |
Top Watch 3(1):18, 2008 |
|
Questions
Regarding iPSC-based Correction of Hemophilia |
Top Watch 4(1):5-6, 2009 |
|
Reaching a realistic assessment on iPSCs
before developing any Reasonable consent for iPSCs |
Top Watch 4(1):7-8, 2009 |
|
Conflict of Interest: Declare or Not to
Declare? |
Scientific Ethics 4(1): 7-8, 2009 |
|
Distinctions
between iPSCs and ESCs Published Earlier |
Top Watch 4(1):18-19, 2009 |
|
Open Public Comments to Public |
Pioneer 4(1): 13-14, 2009 |
|
Cancer Cell Formation by iPS
Techniques: Mechanisms and Testing Approaches |
Logical Biology 9 (1):22-41, 2009 |
|
Distinguishing Cancerous iPSCs from
ESCs |
Top Watch 4(1):20-23, 2009 |
|
Published Insights for Distinctions between iPSCs and ESCs and Why
and How |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):44-51, 2009 |
|
Understanding the Nature and Risk of
Incorrectly Programmed Stem Cells (iPSCs) |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):52-60, 2009 |
|
Over-Stretching iPSC Findings May Cause a Breakage of Public Trust on
Science |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):61-64, 2009 |
|
A Misrepresented Research Finding well
Protected by Nature |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):65-68, 2009 |
|
Abandon an Empty
Stochastic Model and Move Towards a Deterministic Progress for iPSC Research |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):69-76, 2009 |
|
iPS Mice: Passing Acid
Test Or Breaking Basic Ethics? |
Top Watch 4(2):27-28, 2009 |
|
Alternative Views on a Recent PNAS iPSC Publication and Further
Suggestions |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):77-78, 2009 |
|
"Induced" Eyes Might Have Captured Some Truth on
Development |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):79-81, 2009 |
|
A Revelation of Submission Manipulation and Neglect by Nature |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):82-86, 2009 |
|
A Top-Ranked Journal's Low-Level Performance |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):87-88, 2009 |
|
Comments on Liu's Criticisms over iPSC Research |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):89-91, 2009 |
|
Outright Misrepresentation Should Be an Easy Target Amenable to
Invalidation |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):97-107, 2009 |
|
Shi V. Liu's Collection of Rejections by Mainstream Journals:
2008-2009 |
Logical
Biology 9 (1):108-111, 2009 |
|
Why Do We Need "Fully Pluripotent" iPS
Cells? |
Top Watch 4(2):29-30, 2009 |
|
Medical and Ethical Concerns over Using Safety-Unproven iPSCs
for Clinical Treatme |
Sci. Ethics 4(1):9-11, 2009 |
|
A Public Protest against Presenting Gairdner Award to Shinya
Yamanaka |
Sci. Ethics 4(1):12-14, 2009 |
|
Idea Repetition and Credit Robbery in iPS Research and
Publishing |
Sci. Ethics 4(1):18-20, 2009 |
|
Reasons for And Cautions against Near-Final
Version Publications |
Top Watch 4(2):31-32, 2009 |
|
Why Cell Refuses to Show This Comment? |
Top Watch 4(2):33-35, 2009 |
|
A Repeated Objection against a Potential Noble Prize to Yamanaka |
Top Watch 4(2):36-37, 2009 |
|
What Are the Scientific and Ethical Standards for Top Journals? |
Top Watch 4(2):38-41, 2009 |
|
Fast Protest against a Fast Hype on iPS Cells |
Top Watch 4(2):44-47, 2009 |
|
The Method of the Year 2009 and Its Intrinsic Problems |
Logical
Biology 10 (1):1-3, 2010 |
|
From Reprogrammable Mice to Man: Why Misrepresentation Cannot Lead
to Real Application |
Logical
Biology 10 (1):4-9, 2010 |
|
iPS Reprogramming Efficiency Came back to Reality, Finally |
Logical
Biology 10 (1):10-11, 2010 |
|
A Huge iPSC Hype Not Yet Seen through |
Logical
Biology 10 (1):16-18, 2010 |
|
The Mighty Misrepresentations Preserve Problems for iPSCs |
Logical
Biology 10 (1):19-21, 2010 |
|
Are iPSCs really functionally equivalent with ESCs? |
Logical
Biology 10 (1):22-23, 2010 |
|
Moving iPS Research into the Correct Direction |
Logical
Biology 10 (1):24-27, 2010 |
|
A Confirmation of My Earlier Conclusions on iPS Reprogramming
And iPSCs |
Logical
Biology 10 (2):29-35, 2010 |
|
Another Confirmation of My Earlier Discoveries on iPSCs And iPS
Reprogramming |
Logical
Biology 10 (2):36-40, 2010 |
|
"Cherry-Picking": Can We Focus On Those Super
"Cherry-Pickers" Please? |
Sci. Ethics 5(1):1-2, 2010 |
|
Complaint against Nature's Cherry-Picking against Truth And
Discrimination against Truth-Seeking Scientists |
Sci. Ethics 5(1):3-5, 2010 |
* Email SVL8EPA@gmail.com
for the listed papers.
Further
readings on related topics:
Comments
posted on the following websites: